Skip to content

Demystifying Internet Cookies: A Comprehensive Guide

Cookies are embedded into the foundation of the modern internet – but what exactly are these little bits of code doing behind the scenes? This in-depth cookie guide aims to shed light on what cookies are, how they work, and the privacy implications for users.

What Are Cookies and How Do They Work?

Cookies are small text files that websites place on your device to identify your browser and "remember" bits of data. Literal cookies they are not – there‘s no chocolate chip or raisin delight happening here.

When you first visit a new website, it generates a unique cookie ID to assign to your browser or mobile app. It‘s essentially a long string of letters and numbers. The site stores this cookie in your device‘s cache or internet files.

Now, when you return to that same site again, your browser recognizes the cookie and sends it back to the website. This exchange allows the site to "remember" your previous activity.

Think of it like leaving your business card at a shop you visit often. Next time you come back, the shopkeeper recognizes your card and knows, "Ah yes, this customer has been here before!" The cookie serves as your unique identifier.

Here‘s a simple 4-step example of how cookies work:

  1. You visit Website ABC for the first time.
  2. Website ABC sends your browser a cookie and requests to store it.
  3. Your browser stores the cookie in a designated text file.
  4. When you visit Website ABC again, your browser returns the cookie.
  5. Website ABC uses the data in the cookie to remember you.

Cookies enhance site functionality by allowing personalization and tracking user behavior. However, they also have implications for internet privacy, which we‘ll explore throughout this guide.

Types of Cookies

While all cookies work more or less the same way, there are a few main types categorized by who sets them and how they get used:

  • First-party cookies are set directly by the site you are visiting. They generally enable core functionality like saving shopping cart items or remembering your preferences. These are considered low risk.

  • Third-party cookies get set by external parties, like advertising networks or embedded widgets. These cookies are used for cross-site tracking and targeted advertising. More on these later.

  • Session cookies are temporary and erased after you close your browser session. No data gets retained.

  • Persistent cookies remain stored on your device until they expire (anywhere from hours to years) or are manually deleted. They collect data across multiple sessions.

  • Essential cookies are necessary for basic site functions like security, payments, login credentials. Disabling these may break core features.

  • Functional cookies enhance performance and usability by remembering your choices, like language or location preferences.

  • Analytics cookies measure site traffic patterns and user engagement. Common in services like Google Analytics.

  • Advertising/targeting cookies are used to track browsing habits, build user profiles, and serve targeted promotions. Also called tracking cookies.

The Evolution of Cookie Law

Websites haven‘t always had to ask for your cookie consent. Emerging privacy regulations have granted users more control over how their data gets collected online.

  • EU Cookie Directive (2009) – First EU privacy law related to cookies requiring sites to disclose cookie usage. Did not require opt-in consent.

  • GDPR (2018) – Expanded requirements for transparency and opt-in consent before installing cookies and processing data. Fines for non-compliance.

  • CCPA (2020) – Granted California residents the right to opt-out of the sale of their data. Impacted cookie practices.

  • ePrivacy Directive – An upcoming EU regulation to replace the 2009 directive. Sites must gain opt-in cookie consent.

Many sites now display cookie disclaimers and consent notices citing these regulations. Users in the EU and California now have greater control over certain types of tracking.

The Good: Valid Cookie Uses

When utilized properly, cookies do provide some benefits for both users and site owners:

  • Convenience – Cookies enable a smoother browsing experience by remembering your site preferences and login details. No need to reconfigure settings or reauthenticate every visit.

  • Personalization – Sites can customize content and recommendations based on your location, browsing history and previous activity.

  • Shopping Carts – Cookies keep track of items you add to your cart across multiple pages without you having to re-add them every time.

  • Site Analytics – Many sites use first-party analytics cookies to analyze traffic, engagement metrics, and how users navigate their site. These insights help them improve the user experience.

  • Fraud Prevention – Cookies help sites detect malicious bots, phishing scams, and other cyber threats by analyzing user behavior and activity. They provide an added security layer.

When first-party site cookies and analytics cookies come from trusted sources, they pose minimal risk and help enhance the functionality of websites.

The Bad: Cookie Privacy Concerns

However, cookie data practices also raise a few privacy issues that concern consumer advocates and cybersecurity experts:

  • Tracking – Third-party cookies follow users across multiple sites to compile browsing histories and create detailed behavior profiles.

  • Targeted Ads – Data gathered from tracking cookies enables advertisers to serve ultra-targeted promotions. Some find this "surveillance advertising" unsettling.

  • Data Sharing – Cookie data frequently gets packaged, aggregated, and sold to external parties, often without the user‘s knowledge or clear consent.

  • Individual Identification – With enough compiled data points, online profiles created through cookie tracking could potentially identify individuals.

  • Respawning Cookies – Deleted cookies resurrect themselves as "zombie cookies" to re-enable data collection across sites. These are used heavily by advertisers.

  • Security Risks – Cookies could be exploited to steal or scrape sensitive login credentials and enable account takeovers through compromised cookies.

For these reasons, cookies raise some valid questions around internet privacy and how our data gets collected, retained, secured, and shared without our full understanding.

Who Uses Tracking Cookies Most?

Third-party advertising cookies from data brokers, social media platforms, and Google services account for most of the online cross-site tracking activity:

  • Data brokers – Info shared with data brokers gets aggregated into consumer profiles. They provide client companies with marketing data.

  • Social media – Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram leverage cookies to serve targeted ads both on and off their platforms.

  • Google – As the internet‘s top advertising company, Google orchestrates a vast portion of online ad tracking through its multiple ad services and analytics cookies.

Various studies estimate third-party cookies account for anywhere from 42-69% of all cookies set. The majority serve digital advertising in some form.

Cookie Tracking in Action

Let‘s look at a common example of cookie tracking:

  • You browse hiking boots on an outdoor retailer‘s website. Their first-party cookie remembers your search.

  • A Facebook widget on the site drops a third-party cookie to track your visit.

  • Later, you‘re on Instagram and see an ad for hiking boots. The third-party cookie allowed Facebook to target you based on your earlier online activity.

  • Across the web, the cookies continue compiling data about your interests to serve relevant ads. Your browsing history gets commodified.

This simplified example demonstrates how cookies enable online tracking both within individual sites and across the broader internet.

Managing Cookies for Privacy

If this type of universal tracking makes you uncomfortable, you aren‘t powerless when it comes to managing your cookie privacy:

  • Adjust browser settings – Disable third-party cookies or enable "Do Not Track" requests.

  • Use private/incognito modes – Prevents cookies from storing after a session.

  • Install cookie manager – Get granular control over cookie permissions.

  • Clear cookies regularly – Manually wipe your cookies and cache.

  • Use anonymous browsing – TOR and VPNs provide encryption and hide your IP address.

  • Opt out of tracking – Some sites let you opt out of targeted ads.

  • Block ads/trackers – Ad blockers, anti-tracking extensions provide protection.

  • Review cookie policies – Be aware of how each site uses cookies.

Evaluate your personal privacy priorities and find the right balance of cookie management tools that meet your needs.

Expert Perspectives on Cookie Tracking

Privacy advocates and cybersecurity experts have weighed in on the implications of third-party cookie tracking:

  • "The Cambridge Analytica scandal and GDPR have both shown that large-scale web tracking should be opt-in, not opt-out." – Electronic Frontier Foundation

  • "When everything you do online is being watched, we stop behaving like ourselves." – Glenn Greenwald, journalist, on surveillance advertising

  • "You cannot hide on the internet anymore. Cookie data has become a digital fingerprint that allows you to be uniquely identified." – Jayson DeMers, founder of SecurityMetrics

  • "55% of cookies classify as malicious or high risk. Regularly clearing your cookies is a smart security practice." – Awake Security research

  • "Third party cookies often respawn as ‘zombie cookies‘ with a simple reboot. It‘s an unfair practice that undermines user intent." – Bennett Cyphers, EFF

Experts resoundingly agree that users should have transparent understanding and control when it comes to online tracking mechanisms like cookies.

Additional Cookie Questions

Here are answers to some other commonly asked questions about cookies:

Are all cookies bad for privacy?

No. First-party functional and analytics cookies from sites you trust pose minimal risk. It‘s third-party advertising/tracking cookies that warrant more privacy caution.

What‘s the difference between first- and third-party cookies?

First-party cookies come from the owner of the site you are visiting directly. Third-party cookies come from external ad networks, analytics services, social media, etc embedded on the site.

How can I see the cookies on my computer?

You can view all your computer‘s stored cookies through your browser settings or by using a cookie manager plugin. This allows you to view and delete them.

Does deleting cookies improve security?

Regularly wiping your cookies removes potentially malicious ones before they can be exploited. But don‘t over-delete essential site cookies or you may lose functionality.

Can websites steal passwords using cookies?

In theory, yes. Hackers could scrape and abuse cookie data in what‘s called a "cookie stuffing" attack. Use password managers and multi-factor authentication to lower this risk.

Do I have to accept cookies to browse a website?

You can technically browse the modern web without cookies enabled. But expect clunky, broken experiences on many sites. Some cookies are necessary for proper functionality.

Key Takeaways and Conclusion

  • Cookies are small text files that allow websites to identify and remember your browser. They provide a more personalized, functional user experience.

  • Different types of cookies serve different purposes, from essential site functions to third-party tracking and advertising.

  • While very prevalent online, third-party advertising cookies raise reasonable concerns around internet privacy and user data practices.

  • Emerging regulations like GDPR and CCPA now grant users more transparency and control over cookie collection.

  • With a basic understanding of how cookies work and the privacy risks, users can better manage settings and browsing habits to protect their information. Leverage available tools.

  • Find the right balance for you between privacy and functionality. The lowest risk cookies come directly from sites you actively engage with. Be most cautious of third-party collection.

While the tracking capabilities of cookies creates mistrust for some individuals, remember that you ultimately get to decide how much unsolicited data gets collected from your online activity. Stay informed, review site cookie policies, and take advantage of the tools available to tailor your cookie experience.

Tags:
nv-author-image

Streamr Go

StreamrGo is always about privacy, specifically protecting your privacy online by increasing security and better standard privacy practices.