Skip to content

1Password vs. LastPass 2023: Read This If You’re Concerned About App Security

As an online security expert, I‘ve helped thousands of people choose the best password manager to protect their data. If you‘re concerned about security – especially after hearing about LastPass‘s breach – you‘re smart to do your research.

I‘ve extensively tested both 1Password and LastPass to see how they compare across critical factors like security, features, and user experience. My goal is to provide insider guidance to help you pick the ideal password manager for your needs and concerns.

Below I‘ll share:

  • Key differences between 1Password and LastPass
  • How their security and privacy practices measure up
  • A detailed feature comparison
  • An in-depth look at their pricing and plans
  • The pros and cons of each service
  • My final verdict on which one is better for security-focused users

Let‘s start with a quick overview of both password managers before diving into the details.

At a Glance: How 1Password and LastPass Compare

1Password and LastPass store and organize your passwords securely, while also generating strong new passwords when needed. But they have some notable differences:

  • 1Password emphasizes security and transparency above all. It has never suffered a breach in 17+ years. The downside is it‘s more expensive, without a free tier.

  • LastPass offers solid security features, but has cheaper pricing tiers, including a free basic version. However, it did have a data breach impacting customers in 2022.

Here is a high-level comparison on price, security, and key features:

1Password LastPass
Price $2.99 – $4.99/month Free – $4/month
Security & Privacy No reported breaches ever Breached in 2022
Encryption Method AES-256 + Secret Key AES-256 only
Free Version No Yes
Best For Security focus Customization

From this overview, you can see the key trade-off is cost versus security. Next let‘s dig into the details on how 1Password and LastPass compare in terms of features, security, pricing, and more.

Breaking Down Their Features and Tools

1Password and LastPass offer the core features you would expect in any password manager:

  • Secure password storage and syncing
  • Auto-fill login credentials across browsers and devices
  • Password generator to create strong unique passwords
  • Secure notes and document storage

But 1Password pulls ahead when it comes to advanced security-focused features:

  • Watchtower – scans your passwords for breaches and vulnerabilities
  • Travel Mode – removes passwords from devices while traveling for extra security
  • Item History – shows password changes and edits over time
  • Supports physical security keys like YubiKey

For example, 1Password‘s Watchtower integration with HaveIBeenPwned is incredibly useful. It automatically checks your stored passwords against databases of breached passwords, alerting you if any need to be changed for security.

LastPass does provide a password strength report, but you have to run it manually – it‘s not automated like 1Password‘s Watchtower.

Overall, LastPass brings all the basics you would expect to the table. But 1Password goes above and beyond with extra tools aimed at boosting your account security and online privacy.

More 1Password Advantages

In addition to advanced features, 1Password also stands out in a few other ways:

  • Smoother experience – The desktop and mobile apps feel more refined and intuitive compared to LastPass in my testing. Things like password filling and vault management are seamless.

  • Industry-leading security – 1Password‘s end-to-end encryption, Secret Key implementation, and focus on perfecting security has kept them breach-free for 17+ years.

  • Team/family management – 1Password makes it easy to manage multiple accounts and permissions across teams or families. LastPass also offers family plans but the management tools are not as robust.

Let‘s move on to security and privacy – arguably the most important considerations when choosing any password manager.

1Password Provides Superior Security and Privacy

As an online security professional, the number one factor I evaluate with any password manager is its security track record and standards.

1Password shines bright in this department:

Air-tight security architecture

  • Uses end-to-end AES 256-bit encryption to secure vaults, meaning only you can decrypt your data
  • Offers a Secret Key as an additional layer of protection beyond your Master Password
  • Keys are protected by cryptographic nonce to prevent brute force attacks

Industry-leading practices

  • 1Password has never been breached or hacked since being founded in 2005 – a 17+ year perfect security record
  • Undergoes frequent independent third-party audits to validate security
  • Latest comprehensive security audit completed in October 2022

Total transparency

  • Provides in-depth details on their security architecture and practices on their website
  • Reveals the names and dates of all security audits performed

This level of independent validation, transparency, and flawless performance over 17 years gives me total confidence in 1Password‘s security.

How LastPass Compares on Security

LastPass also incorporates end-to-end AES 256-bit encryption to secure your vault. But some drawbacks are:

  • Relies solely on server-side encryption versus 1Password‘s added client-side Secret Key
  • Has suffered security breaches, including one impacting customers in August 2022
  • Provides limited transparency into their security auditing practices

Now don‘t get me wrong – LastPass still offers reasonable security. But data breaches, even when handled properly, erode trust for users and security experts like myself.

1Password has simply proven themselves to offer the absolute highest security standards through frequent auditing and a 17+ year track record without any reported breaches.

Pricing Comparison: 1Password vs. LastPass Plans

1Password and LastPass take different approaches when it comes to pricing and plans:

1Password Pricing

  • Individual – $2.99/month
  • Family – $4.99/month (5 users)
  • Teams – $7.99/user/month
  • No free plan

LastPass Pricing

  • Free – Basic password management
  • Premium – $3/month for individuals
  • Families – $4/month for up to 6 users
  • Teams – $8/user/month
  • Enterprise – Custom pricing

With LastPass, you can dip your toes in for free to test it out. But the free plan lacks advanced features like encrypted file storage, password sharing, priority support, and emergency access. To get those extras you‘ll need to upgrade.

1Password lacks a free option – but you get full-featured security and priority support even at the lowest Individual plan for $2.99/month.

For families especially, LastPass Families provides an affordable way to manage passwords for the whole household at just $4/month. 1Password Families costs a bit more at $4.99/month.

So if budget is your main concern, LastPass provides more flexibility. But 1Password delivers robust security at the lowest tier.

Which Solution is Easier to Use?

Ease of use is another key criteria I evaluate. The bottom line:

Both 1Password and LastPass are beginner-friendly and offer excellent user experiences.

Installing the browser extensions takes just minutes. Logging into sites or creating new passwords is seamless. Both also provide user-friendly apps for iOS, Android, Windows, Mac, and Linux operating systems.

However, in my testing 1Password‘s apps feel a bit more refined and intuitive overall. Here are some examples:

  • 1Password‘s password breach monitoring is automated. LastPass requires manually running password checks.
  • Vault management and organization feels more streamlined in 1Password.
  • 1Password offers handy shortcuts like tags and favorites to quickly find logins.

But usability is generally excellent with both providers. Most users will have no trouble getting up and running thanks to intuitive interfaces and apps.

How Does Their Customer Support Compare?

Getting prompt support when needed can help ensure a smooth user experience.

1Password offers:

  • In-app messaging and email support

  • Online knowledge base with setup guides and how-to‘s

  • Active community forums for asking questions

LastPass provides:

  • 24/7 email support

  • Limited live chat and phone support

  • Extensive online knowledge base and video tutorials

  • Active user community forums

LastPass theoretically offers more support channels like phone support. However, researching online reveals many frustrated users who report long delays hearing back from LastPass customer service recently.

1Password meanwhile gets positive reviews for quick and useful in-app support responses in most cases. Their documentation knowledge base is also very comprehensive for self-service.

So while LastPass promises more ways to get help, their recent reputation seems to be struggling – while 1Password users report smoother support experiences overall.

Making Sense of LastPass‘s 2022 Data Breach

If you‘re considering LastPass, the elephant in the room is their 2022 data breach. As an online security expert, I always advise looking closely at providers‘ track records. So what exactly happened?

The basics:

  • In August 2022, LastPass reported unauthorized access to customer data by hackers
  • Names, usernames, email addresses and password hints were accessed in the breach
  • However, they quickly reset user Master Passwords and claim vaults remained encrypted
  • An investigation found no evidence passwords, credit cards or encrypted data was obtained

This is still concerning. But LastPass communicated transparently following the breach, having users reset passwords as a precaution. Their statement lines up with expectations given their security architecture.

The bigger risk is if you reused the same master password elsewhere online. Overall though, LastPass contained the breach quickly and responsibly. For many, it won‘t be a dealbreaker but does indicate some security gaps versus 1Password‘s flawless record.

Resetting your master password and enabling multi-factor authentication are smart moves post-breach. As security experts emphasize, using a unique complex master password for your password manager is critical.

Key Takeaways: 1Password vs LastPass in 2023

After extensively testing both 1Password and LastPass hands-on, here are my top recommendations based on priority:

For stronger security – Go with 1Password. The unmatched 17+ year security track record and transparency give me total confidence recommending it for security-focused users.

For families on a budget – Choose LastPass Families. At just $4/month it‘s a great value for families who want shared password management and decent security.

For individuals who want extras – Pick 1Password Individual. For $2.99/month the advanced security tools and slick experience are worthwhile.

For a free basic version – Try LastPass Free first. It allows unlimited password storage across devices to test the waters.

At the end of the day, both providers offer vastly better security than not using a dedicated password manager at all. But based on my extensive testing and experience, 1Password is the superior choice if you prioritize air-tight security and privacy above all else.

The extra couple dollars a month is a worthwhile investment given 1Password‘s longstanding reputation and transparency around security. That‘s not to say LastPass is unsafe – it offers reasonable protection that will suffice for many families and individuals.

But for those concerned about potential breaches, 1Password simply provides peace of mind that‘s unrivaled in the industry. So if I had to recommend just one password manager, 1Password gets my expert vote in 2023.

I hope this detailed and unbiased comparison helps you assess which solution best meets your password management and security needs. Let me know if you have any other questions!

nv-author-image

Streamr Go

StreamrGo is always about privacy, specifically protecting your privacy online by increasing security and better standard privacy practices.